How to begin, who follows the
societal rules, and who doesn’t and how does that help or hinder that person? I wanted to pick a secondary
character for this, because not only can they sometimes be the greatest
characters written unintentionally but because they sometimes give more insight
to the true nature of the people of the time. Take Sylvie for example. A strong
woman of color who was married, and refuses to get married again throughout the
book to prove that she can be faithful to her husband with her second chance.
She now owns the boardinghouse, and runs it with grace and precision that I don’t
think she would have had were she a man, or were she a white woman. She takes her
own path even though she is a woman of color, which is something that Jenkins
characters seem to have. Well, the characters we like anyhow. Mind you, it’s
not easy for her, but she wants to prove a point, plus when her husband dies in
the mines, she doesn’t have very many options. Sylvie still makes her own way
in the world though, and stays her strong, independent self the whole book. I
think that she only agrees to marry Doc because she realizes that it is okay
for her to be happy even without her husband, and that her husband would want
her to forgive herself for the things that she did in the past.
I guess she fits pretty well into
the social construction of gender, because she acts as a woman is thought to
ask, be her more stubborn that the average woman. She doesn’t do anything too
outlandish, and she wears dresses as expected of the time. All that seems to
suit her just fine though, whereas Eddy for example doesn’t want to give up her
dream just to be a quiet mother, and wife. On the other hand, Sylvie’s ability
to scare off both Jim, and Rhine from disobeying her is a pretty awesome feat
that takes a lot of guts and passion it takes “hutzpah”. Both Eddy and Sylvie
both seem to have this trait, as well as some of the other women of color in
the community. I would say that Sylvie is treated
as any other woman of color in the community, and treated with at least some with
a large measure of respect for taking her own path through her life. Her denial
of the obvious affection she has for Doc do get in the way of her being happy,
but in the end, she accepts it and can be herself. She too has an H.E.A. ending
to her story. The way that her own story mirrors Eddy's in some ways is a cool dynamic too.
Whoa. I think what you pointed out with Sylvia's relationship and Eddy's was quite interesting. Also pointing out the similarities that she and Eddy has. I guess I never really thought about Sylvia and what type of person she was because she wasn't the main character. I like how you decided to focus it on a person different from all of ours (mainly Rhine and Eddy).
ReplyDeleteOverall, I really like how you chose to focus on a side character instead of one of the main characters. I never thought about how Sylvie's own story kind of "mirrors" Eddy's in some odd but cool way. They're both woman of color, strong independent beings, but in the end, still have wants and desires that are finally granted in the end (marrying Doc).
ReplyDeleteI think you did a great job depicting the characters. In a way, when you look at Sylvie's life, it's kind of foreshadowing Eddy's life. Coming from the same social background and class, there are quite a few similarities. Eddy is torn on what to do with her love with Rhine and Sylvie faces the same situation with Doc. But in the end, love trumps all.
ReplyDeleteThe connection between Sylvie and Eddy is an important one, and makes me think if there are some stereotypes about "strong women of color" that are promoted in the book?
ReplyDelete